google
yahoo
bing

Hindsight 20/20 - 1.

Thanks to Arunn who is the inspiration behind what I hope will be a series of posts.

The longest-running and perhaps the most influential journal archive in Science, that of the Royal Society of England, is available now for FREE to anyone on the internet to explore. 350 years of scientific study is now available online in the Royal Society Journals Digital Archive following its official launch this week.

Curiosity aroused, I visited the archives and started browsing from the earliest of the archives looking for anything of interest in medicine and the biological sciences.

The first volume of the Philosophical Transactions covering the years 1665 to 1666 AD revealed a gem, titled ‘Observables upon a Monstrous Head,’ which is the subject of this post. No author is specified. But as the article reveals, it is a report of the observations made by Robert Boyle of Boyle’s Law fame.

Here is the article in its entirety, spelling, syntax and all….(NB. The annotations in the figure were missing in the original)

This was the Head of a Colt, reprefented in the annexed Figure 4. firft viewed by Mr. Boyle, who went into the stable where the Colt lay, and got the Head haftily and rudely cut off, the Body thereof appearing to his Eye compleatly formed, without any Monftrofity to be taken notice of in it. Afterwards he caufed it to be put into a Veffel, and covered with Spirit of Wine, thereby chiefly intending, to give good example, together with a proof, that by the help of the faid spirit, (which he hath recommended for fuch Properties in one of his Effays of the Ufefulnefs of Natural Philofophy) the parts of Animals, and even Monfters, may in Summer it felf be preferved long enough, to afford Anatomifts the opportunities of examining them.Figure 4.

The Head being opened, and examined, it was found,

Firft, That it had no fign of any Nofe in the ufual place, nor had it any, in any other place of the Head, unlefs the double Bagg CC, that grew out of the midft of the forehead, were fome rudiment of it.
Next, That the two Eyes were united into one Double Eye, which was placed juft in the middle of the Brow, the Nofe being wanting, which fhould have feparated them, whereby the two Eye-holes in the Scull were united into one very large round hole, into the midft of which, from the Brain, entred one prety large Optick Nerve, at the end of which grew a great Double Eye; that is, that Membrane, called Sclerotis, which contained both, was one and the fame, but feemed to have a Seam, by which they were joined, to go quite round it, and the fore or pellucid part was diftinctly feparated into two Cornea’s by a white Seam that divided them. Each Cornea feemed to have its Iris, (or Rain-bow-like Circle) and Apertures or Pupils diftinct; and upon opening the Cornea, there was found within it two Balls, or Cryftalline Humours, very well fhaped; but the other parts of it could not be fo well diftinguifhed, becaufe the eye had been much bruifed by the handling, and the inner parts confufed and diflocated. It had four Eye-browes, placed in the manner exprft in Figure 4. by a a, bb; aa reprefenting the lower, and bb, upper Eyelids.
Laftly, That juft above the Eyes, as it were in the midft of the Forehead, was a very deep depreffion, and out of the midft of that grew a kind of double Purfe or Bagg, CC, conatining little or nothing it it; but to fome it feemed to be a production of the matter defigned for the Nofe, but diverted by this Monftrous Conception; perhaps the Procffus mammillares joined into one, and covered with a thin hairy skin.

———–

This is probably the oldest published description of Holoprosencephaly.

It is a pity that the Honourable Mr. Boyle and his colleagues did not open the skull and describe the deformed brain.

Scott F. Gilbert’s Developmental Biology site has this to say about holoprosencephaly…

The holoprosencephalic conditions are graded from the most severe cases (which are lethal) to mild abnormalities only recognizable by physicians looking for such things. The most severe type, where a single forebrain vesicle is formed without any evidence of division into left or right hemispheres, is cyclopia. Here, a nose-like proboscis extends over a single, medial eye (Figure 1A,B).

The entire very informative article and the accompanying figures including one on the phenotypic spectrum of holoprosencephaly can be seen here.

Coincidentally, Holoprosencephaly featured in the very first medical post in my blog.

Alobar Holoprosencephaly - antenatal ultrasonogram

Dysmorphic facies with proboscis - antenatal 3D ultrasonogram This is a condition, at least the more severe varieties of which should be diagnosed antenatally on ultrasound especially with newer advances such as 3D and 4D ultrasonography and obstetric MRI.

A video of an antenatal ultrasonogram showing alobar holoprosencephaly can be seen here.

Here is an excellent set of images of holoprosencephaly diagnosed on fetal MRI.

More articles on the diagnosis of holoprosencephaly can be read here, here and here.

And finally, here’s something that will interest my friend TJ.

Start Slide Show with PicLens Lite PicLens

6 Responses to “Hindsight 20/20 - 1.”  

  1. 1 Moof

    Vijay, those are fascinating in a very uncomfortable (train wreck - don’t wanna look, but can’t help it!) sort of way. Looking forward to the rest of your offerings in this area!

    Thank you!

  2. 2 It's me, T.J.

    Hey Scanman…

    Thanks for the link!

    *smile*

    Like Moof says… these “accidents” are horrible, yet it’s hard to turn away from their mysteries.

    later…

  3. 3 Moof

    Vijay … you’ve been tagged!

  4. 4 karrvakarela

    Hi Vijay,

    Just dropping by to say thanks for your comments. It’s a very nice site you have here! Radiology has never been my forte, especially ultrasounds (they all look like the sea to me), but I look forward to learning from your posts.

    Cheers,

    kk

  5. 5 Nick

    Very interesting. It will be lots of fun reading through those old journals.

    FYI, the odd letter that you have transcribed as f (as in “monftrofity”) is actually a long “s.” If you look closely, you’ll see that it is printed differently than the lowercase “f.” For one thing, the long “s” has a shorter crossbar. IIRC, it is roughly equivalent to the German letter that looks a bit like a capital “B” or Greek Beta, and it dropped out of use in English writing around 1800. The equivalent in modern typefaces would be the standard lowercase “s”

  6. 6 Mom of HPE baby

    Thanks for posting about this in a respectful way. We found out my oldest son (2nd child)had HPE when he was 16 weeks gestation. And Terminated shorty after. I am SICK of cyclops’ being called monsters and “creatures” and school children being told they are mythological!. Thanks again for this article!

Leave a Reply